284. Length ContractionLearning Objectives
Have you ever driven on a road that seems like it goes on forever? If you look ahead, you might say you have about 10 km left to go. Another traveler might say the road ahead looks like it’s about 15 km long. If you both measured the road, however, you would agree. Traveling at everyday speeds, the distance you both measure would be the same. You will read in this section, however, that this is not true at relativistic speeds. Close to the speed of light, distances measured are not the same when measured by different observers. Proper LengthOne thing all observers agree upon is relative speed. Even though clocks measure different elapsed times for the same process, they still agree that relative speed, which is distance divided by elapsed time, is the same. This implies that distance, too, depends on the observer’s relative motion. If two observers see different times, then they must also see different distances for relative speed to be the same to each of them. The muon discussed in Section 283 Example 1 illustrates this concept. To an observer on the Earth, the muon travels at $0.950c$ for $7.05\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\mu \mathrm{s}$ from the time it is produced until it decays. Thus it travels a distance $${L}_{0}=v\mathrm{\Delta}t=(0.950)(3.00\times {\text{10}}^{8}\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\text{m/s})(7.05\times {\text{10}}^{6}\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\text{s})=2.01\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\text{km}$$relative to the Earth. In the muon’s frame of reference, its lifetime is only $2.20\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\mu \mathrm{s}$. It has enough time to travel only $$L=v\mathrm{\Delta}{t}_{0}=(0\text{.}\text{950})(3\text{.}\text{00}\times {\text{10}}^{8}\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\text{m/s})(2\text{.}\text{20}\times {\text{10}}^{6}\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\text{s})=0\text{.627 km}.$$The distance between the same two events (production and decay of a muon) depends on who measures it and how they are moving relative to it. Proper Length
The Earthbound observer measures the proper length ${L}_{0}$, because the points at which the muon is produced and decays are stationary relative to the Earth. To the muon, the Earth, air, and clouds are moving, and so the distance $L$ it sees is not the proper length. Length ContractionTo develop an equation relating distances measured by different observers, we note that the velocity relative to the Earthbound observer in our muon example is given by $$v=\frac{{L}_{0}}{\mathrm{\Delta}t}.$$The time relative to the Earthbound observer is $\mathrm{\Delta}t$, since the object being timed is moving relative to this observer. The velocity relative to the moving observer is given by $$v=\frac{L}{\mathrm{\Delta}{t}_{0}}.$$The moving observer travels with the muon and therefore observes the proper time $\mathrm{\Delta}{t}_{0}$. The two velocities are identical; thus, $$\frac{{L}_{0}}{\mathrm{\Delta}t}=\frac{L}{\mathrm{\Delta}{t}_{0}}.$$We know that $\mathrm{\Delta}t=\gamma \mathrm{\Delta}{t}_{0}$. Substituting this equation into the relationship above gives $$L=\frac{{L}_{0}}{\gamma}.$$Substituting for $\gamma $ gives an equation relating the distances measured by different observers. Length Contraction
If we measure the length of anything moving relative to our frame, we find its length $L$ to be smaller than the proper length ${L}_{0}$ that would be measured if the object were stationary. For example, in the muon’s reference frame, the distance between the points where it was produced and where it decayed is shorter. Those points are fixed relative to the Earth but moving relative to the muon. Clouds and other objects are also contracted along the direction of motion in the muon’s reference frame. Example 1: Calculating Length Contraction: The Distance between Stars Contracts when You Travel at High VelocitySuppose an astronaut, such as the twin discussed in Simultaneity and Time Dilation, travels so fast that $\gamma =\text{30}\text{.}\text{00}$. (a) She travels from the Earth to the nearest star system, Alpha Centauri, 4.300 light years (ly) away as measured by an Earthbound observer. How far apart are the Earth and Alpha Centauri as measured by the astronaut? (b) In terms of $c$, what is her velocity relative to the Earth? You may neglect the motion of the Earth relative to the Sun. (See Figure 3.) Strategy First note that a light year (ly) is a convenient unit of distance on an astronomical scale—it is the distance light travels in a year. For part (a), note that the 4.300 ly distance between the Alpha Centauri and the Earth is the proper distance ${L}_{0}$, because it is measured by an Earthbound observer to whom both stars are (approximately) stationary. To the astronaut, the Earth and the Alpha Centauri are moving by at the same velocity, and so the distance between them is the contracted length $L$. In part (b), we are given $\gamma $, and so we can find $v$ by rearranging the definition of $\gamma $ to express $v$ in terms of $c$. Solution for (a)
Solution for (b)
Discussion First, remember that you should not round off calculations until the final result is obtained, or you could get erroneous results. This is especially true for special relativity calculations, where the differences might only be revealed after several decimal places. The relativistic effect is large here ($\text{\gamma =}\text{30}\text{.}\text{00}$), and we see that $v$ is approaching (not equaling) the speed of light. Since the distance as measured by the astronaut is so much smaller, the astronaut can travel it in much less time in her frame. People could be sent very large distances (thousands or even millions of light years) and age only a few years on the way if they traveled at extremely high velocities. But, like emigrants of centuries past, they would leave the Earth they know forever. Even if they returned, thousands to millions of years would have passed on the Earth, obliterating most of what now exists. There is also a more serious practical obstacle to traveling at such velocities; immensely greater energies than classical physics predicts would be needed to achieve such high velocities. This will be discussed in Relatavistic Energy. Why don’t we notice length contraction in everyday life? The distance to the grocery shop does not seem to depend on whether we are moving or not. Examining the equation $L={L}_{0}\sqrt{1\frac{{v}^{2}}{{c}^{2}}}$, we see that at low velocities ($v\text{<<}c$) the lengths are nearly equal, the classical expectation. But length contraction is real, if not commonly experienced. For example, a charged particle, like an electron, traveling at relativistic velocity has electric field lines that are compressed along the direction of motion as seen by a stationary observer. (See Figure 4.) As the electron passes a detector, such as a coil of wire, its field interacts much more briefly, an effect observed at particle accelerators such as the 3 km long Stanford Linear Accelerator (SLAC). In fact, to an electron traveling down the beam pipe at SLAC, the accelerator and the Earth are all moving by and are length contracted. The relativistic effect is so great than the accelerator is only 0.5 m long to the electron. It is actually easier to get the electron beam down the pipe, since the beam does not have to be as precisely aimed to get down a short pipe as it would down one 3 km long. This, again, is an experimental verification of the Special Theory of Relativity. Check Your UnderstandingA particle is traveling through the Earth’s atmosphere at a speed of $0\text{.}\text{750}c$. To an Earthbound observer, the distance it travels is 2.50 km. How far does the particle travel in the particle’s frame of reference? Show/Hide Solution Answer$${\text{L=L}}_{0}\sqrt{1\frac{{v}^{2}}{{c}^{2}}}=(2\text{.}\text{50 km})\sqrt{1\frac{(0\text{.}\text{750}c{)}^{2}}{{c}^{2}}}=\text{1}\text{.}\text{65 km}$$ Summary
Conceptual QuestionsExercise 1To whom does an object seem greater in length, an observer moving with the object or an observer moving relative to the object? Which observer measures the object’s proper length? Exercise 2Relativistic effects such as time dilation and length contraction are present for cars and airplanes. Why do these effects seem strange to us? Exercise 3Suppose an astronaut is moving relative to the Earth at a significant fraction of the speed of light. (a) Does he observe the rate of his clocks to have slowed? (b) What change in the rate of Earthbound clocks does he see? (c) Does his ship seem to him to shorten? (d) What about the distance between stars that lie on lines parallel to his motion? (e) Do he and an Earthbound observer agree on his velocity relative to the Earth? Problems & ExercisesExercise 1A spaceship, 200 m long as seen on board, moves by the Earth at $0\text{.}\text{970}c$. What is its length as measured by an Earthbound observer? Show/Hide Solution Solution48.6 m Exercise 2How fast would a 6.0 mlong sports car have to be going past you in order for it to appear only 5.5 m long? Exercise 3(a) How far does the muon in Section 283 Example 1 travel according to the Earthbound observer? (b) How far does it travel as viewed by an observer moving with it? Base your calculation on its velocity relative to the Earth and the time it lives (proper time). (c) Verify that these two distances are related through length contraction $\text{\gamma =}3\text{.}\text{20}$. Show/Hide Solution Solution(a) 1.387 km = 1.39 km (b) 0.433 km (c) $\begin{array}{}L=\frac{{L}_{0}}{\gamma}=\frac{1.387\times {10}^{3}\phantom{\rule{0.25em}{0ex}}\text{m}}{3.20}\\ & =& \mathrm{433.4\; m}=\text{0.433 km}\end{array}$ Thus, the distances in parts (a) and (b) are related when $\gamma =\text{3.20}$. Exercise 4(a) How long would the muon in Section 283 Example 1 have lived as observed on the Earth if its velocity was $0\text{.}\text{0500}c$? (b) How far would it have traveled as observed on the Earth? (c) What distance is this in the muon’s frame? Exercise 5(a) How long does it take the astronaut in Example 1 to travel 4.30 ly at $0\text{.99944}c$ (as measured by the Earthbound observer)? (b) How long does it take according to the astronaut? (c) Verify that these two times are related through time dilation with $\text{\gamma =}\text{30}\text{.}\text{00}$ as given. Show/Hide Solution Solution(a) 4.303 y (to four digits to show any effect) (b) 0.1434 y (c) $\text{\Delta t}={\text{\gamma \Delta t}}_{0}\Rightarrow \gamma =\frac{\text{\Delta t}}{{\text{\Delta t}}_{0}}=\frac{4\text{.}\text{303 y}}{0\text{.}\text{1434 y}}=\text{30}\text{.}0$ Thus, the two times are related when $\text{\gamma =}\text{30}\text{.}\text{00}$. Exercise 6(a) How fast would an athlete need to be running for a 100m race to look 100 yd long? (b) Is the answer consistent with the fact that relativistic effects are difficult to observe in ordinary circumstances? Explain. Exercise 7Unreasonable Results (a) Find the value of $\gamma $ for the following situation. An astronaut measures the length of her spaceship to be 25.0 m, while an Earthbound observer measures it to be 100 m. (b) What is unreasonable about this result? (c) Which assumptions are unreasonable or inconsistent? Show/Hide Solution Solution(a) 0.250 (b) $\gamma $ must be ≥1 (c) The Earthbound observer must measure a shorter length, so it is unreasonable to assume a longer length. Exercise 8Unreasonable Results A spaceship is heading directly toward the Earth at a velocity of $0\text{.}\text{800}c$. The astronaut on board claims that he can send a canister toward the Earth at $1\text{.}\text{20}c$ relative to the Earth. (a) Calculate the velocity the canister must have relative to the spaceship. (b) What is unreasonable about this result? (c) Which assumptions are unreasonable or inconsistent?
